4386 Tarrytown Court, New Albany, OH 43054 (MLS# 226032033)

4386 Tarrytown Court, New Albany, OH 43054

$2,100,000

110-web-or-mls-DJI_20260708172901_0816_D

102-web-or-mls-DJI_20260708172532_0806_D

103-web-or-mls-DJI_20260708172548_0807_D

100-web-or-mls-DJI_20260708172357_0802_D

109-web-or-mls-DJI_20260708172849_0815_D

111-web-or-mls-DJI_20260708172942_0818_D

112-web-or-mls-DJI_20260708173110_0822_D

113-web-or-mls-DJI_20260708173124_0823_D

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 6 Baths: 6 Square Footage: 5,416 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 43,996 Status: Closed

Current Price: $2,100,000 List Date: 8/24/2026 Last Modified: 8/24/2026

Overview

Description

This exceptional custom home in the prestigious Fenway, one of New Albany's original country club communities, offers a rare combination of privacy, scenic views, and an unbeatable location. Set on a coveted one-acre lot overlooking Fenway pond and surrounded by mature trees, the property feels like a private retreat while remaining within walking distance of the country club, Market Street, and New Albany's extensive walking paths. Timeless Georgian architecture pairs beautifully with modern updates throughout the thoughtfully designed interior. The open floor plan features dark hardwood floors, three gas-log fireplaces, a custom kitchen remodeled in 2021 with stone countertops, large center island, gas cooktop, and adjoining wet bar. The main-level owner's suite offers a spa-inspired bath and walk-in closet, while four additional bedrooms and two full baths are located upstairs. Over the garage you will find a generous mother-in-law suite with additional storage closets and anothe ... (Read more)

Listing Details MLS# 226032033

Location Property Info

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
Original List Price: 2100000
Street #: 4386
Street Name: Tarrytown
Street Suffix: Court
County: Franklin
State: OH
Zip Code: 43054
School District: NEW ALBANY PLAIN LSD 2508 FRA CO.
Township: Plain
Subdiv/Cmplx/Comm: NACC/Fenway

OfficeContract Info

MLS Entry Date: 2026-08-23

General Property Info

Total Baths: 6
Baths F.H: 5.1
Full Baths: 5
Half Baths: Yes
Built Prior to 1978: No
Garage/EnclosdSpaces: 3
Year Built: 1994
SqFt Documented: 5416
Documented SqFt Source: Realist
SqFt ATFLS: 6499
ATFLS Source: Realist
Acreage: 1.01
Manufactured Housing Y/N: No
HOA/COA Y/N: Yes
Assoc/Condo Fee: 396
Association Fee Frequency: Quarterly

Tax Info

Parcel #: 222-001480
Tax Year: 2025
Tax Abatement: No
Taxes (Yrly): 27088.16

Remarks Misc

Directions: Refer to GPS Cul-de-sac off of Olmsted Road

Status Change Info

Under Contract Date: 2026-08-23
Sold Date: 2026-08-23
Sold Price/SqFt: 387.74

More Information

Bedroom Level

Beds UP1: 5
Beds Entry Level: Yes

Full Baths Level

Full Baths UP1: 3
Full B Entry Level: Yes
Full Baths Down1: Yes

Half Baths Level

Half B Entry Level: Yes

Living Room Level

Living R Entry Level: Yes

Dining Room Level

Dining Entry Level: Yes

Eating Space Level

Eating S Entry Level: Yes

Family Room Level

Family Room Down1: Yes

Great Room Level

Great R Entry Level: Yes

Rec Room Level

Rec Room Down1: Yes

Utility Space Level

Utility Entry Level: Yes

Basement

Basement Y/N: Yes

Accessory Dwelling Unit

Existing Accessory Dwelling Unit: No

Accessible Features

Accessible Features: No

Auction Info

Auction/Online Bidding Y/N: No

Green Features

Green Features Y/N: No

Property Features

Levels: Two Architectural Style: Traditional Common Walls: No Common Walls Addl Acceptance Cond: None Known Parking Features: Attached Garage; Garage Door Opener; Side Load Basement Description: Egress Window(s); Full Foundation: Poured Exterior: Brick Rooms: 1st Flr Primary Suite; 1st Flr Laundry; 3-Season Room; Bonus Room; Dining Room; Eat Space/Kit; Great Room; Living Room; Mother-In-Law Suite; Rec Rm/Bsmt Fireplace: Three; Gas Log Heating: Gas Air Conditioning: Central Air Windows: Insulated All Interior Flooring: Carpet; Vinyl; Wood Sewer: Public Sewer Exterior Amenities: Irrigation System Water Source: Public Interior Amenities: Dishwasher; Gas Range; Humidifier; Microwave; Refrigerator; Security System; Whirlpool/Tub Patio and Porch Features: Patio; Screened Lot Characteristics: Cul-De-Sac; Water View; Wooded MLS Primary PhotoSrc: Realtor Provided Printing Services: Other Print Project - Call

Listing Office: Engel & Volkers Real Estate Advisors

Listing Agent: Lauren Davie

Last Updated: August - 24 - 2026

The data relating to real estate for sale on this site comes from the Broker Reciprocity/IDX of Columbus Board of Realtors Multiple Listing Service.Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. Columbus Board of Realtors Multiple Listing Service does not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. Copyright 2026 Columbus Board of Realtors. All rights reserved.