260 McCoy Avenue, Worthington, OH 43085 (MLS# 225019031)

260 McCoy Avenue, Worthington, OH 43085

$1,300,000

This custom built home by Arcaro & LaRussa Builders features 5 Bedrooms, 4.1 Bathrooms and 5107 SqFt of exceptional living space in the heart of Worthington. Let's go take a look....

Virtual Tour

https://vimeo.com/1087252220/838e86c07a?ts=0&share=copy

Enjoy the convenience of an attached 3-car garage with loads of extra perks. The garage is wider than the standard size garage and designed to fit 4 cars when equipped with a car lift, accommodated by 15' ceiling and 240 Volt outlet already installed.

A perfect covered porch extends living space outside in a private setting inside the fenced yard.

Enjoy a lush lawn and privacy fence in this Worthington backyard, well-suited for pets and play.

An elegant front entrance to this magnificent property

Step inside to the foyer with 10' ceiling and stunning wood floors that flow throughout the entry level

A generously sized room wrapped in wainscotting and crown molding with a modern chandelier could serve as a beautiful dining room or formal living room.

French doors open to the gorgeous family room with coffered ceiling.

From the built-in bookshelves to the coffered ceiling, every feature of this home was expertly designed and executed.

A reclaimed rustic barn wood mantel crowns the gas log fireplace, beautifully accented by a dramatic floor-to-ceiling stone hearth that adds warmth and character to the space.

Attention to every detail and every comfort has been thoughtfully planned in this home for all seasons.

Enjoy the wall of oversized windows with custom shades overlooking the backyard with easy access to the covered porch in this open concept floor plan.

A chef quality kitchen awaits you and features a 42" Sub-Zero stainless steel fridge & premium appliances.

Enjoy a large quartz island with seating in this amazing gourmet kitchen.

Designed to entertain, this open concept floor plan features a generous eating area and seating at the island.

Ryan Groff custom cabinetry will stand the test of time and make your work spaces incredibly functional while maintaining unmatched beauty in this curated design.

The amazing butlers pantry is a dream come true providing exceptional organization space, right off the main kitchen.

The home cook will delight in this spacious kitchen with incredible space to accommodate a holiday pie making session and a standard week night nosh.

Everything has been considered for the modern kitchen including the double wall ovens, Jenn-Air 5-burner gas cooktop, microwave drawer and even a custom swoop cooktop hood.

From hosting the holiday dinner parties to book club, this open concept floor plan will continue to delight and surprise you.

Amazing attention to detail includes the double spice drawers and beautiful tile backsplash.

A spacious eating area with chandelier lighting is bathed in natural light and well-suited for a large dining table.

The dry bar with beverage coolers and custom cabinetry is amazing.

The mud-room features custom shoe caddies with venting and a place for everyone to unload the coats, gear and backpacks upon arrival

The hardworking laundry room features incredible attention to detail with space to hang clothes, shelving and cabinetry.

Elegant staircase and lighting bring you to the second story.

A beautiful & spacious primary suite features a tray ceiling and a bonus sitting area.

This suite offers a peaceful retreat with space to unwind

Sitting area off the primary suite offers flexible space to use your way

Primary en suite with a gorgeous soaking tub

Enjoy a glass enclosed walk-in shower and a soaking tub in the primary en suite

The en suite features a vanity & dual sinks with an abundance of counter and storage space

Custom walk-in closet by Midwest Closets

Basement level is finished with an incredible wet bar, bedroom suite and great room with wonderful space to play.

Entertain in style with this fantastic wet bar. The LL fridge doesn't convey with the house.

Enjoy the custom wet bar featuring a brick backsplash, locked cabinet and even a garbage disposal. They thought of everything!

From St. Patrick's Day to weekend game night, the custom bar is an excellent feature you will enjoy for years to come.

Be the best host with this custom wet bar in the finished lower level.

This expansive finished lower level includes ample space to live, work and play in style.

Set up your pool table or keep it simple with Foosball in this super sized recreation space.

Bedroom #5 features an egress windows and offers an excellent guest room.

AMAZING storage space with sturdy shelving is featured in the lower level

Back of the home (Children's play structure does not remain)

Proximity to the Village Green in the heart of Old Worthington - home to the famous Farmer's Market.

Proximity to many favorite eateries, including Dewey's Pizza

When you're craving French Onion Soup or a Baguette, La Chatelaine is another favorite local eatery in downtown Worthington.

Enjoy proximity to pubs, shops and delightful urban gathering spaces throughout downtown Worthington.

Proximity to many coveted local shops and businesses throughout the Worthington area. The tree-lined streets and brick sidewalks offer a welcoming setting to enjoy the city.

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 5 Baths: 5 Square Footage: 3,574 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 9,148 Status: Closed

Current Price: $1,300,000 List Date: 5/30/2025 Last Modified: 7/03/2025

Overview

Description

Timeless Elegance Meets Modern Comfort in the Heart of Worthington! Ideally situated between historic Old Worthington and the architectural beauty of Rush Creek, this custom-built home by Arcaro & LaRussa Builders (2019) blends classic tradition with contemporary design. Enjoy a premier location with easy access to the Worthington Farmers Market, top-rated schools, exceptional dining, and boutique shopping, all nestled within a community known for its mature trees and stunning homes. Meticulously maintained by its original owner, the home welcomes you in with 10-foot ceilings in the entry, arched openings, herringbone details, and timeless hardwood floors. The heart of the home is a chef's dream kitchen featuring handcrafted Ryan Groff cabinetry, a Blanco scratch-resistant sink, custom hood, high-end stainless appliances, and a generous island that invites casual mornings and seamless entertaining. A butler's pantry adds both beauty and function. The open-concept family room is anchore ... (Read more)

Listing Details MLS# 225019031

Location Property Info

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
Original List Price: 1300000
Street #: 260
Street Name: McCoy
Street Suffix: Avenue
County: Franklin
State: OH
Zip Code: 43085
School District: WORTHINGTON CSD 2516 FRA CO.
Township: Sharon
Subdiv/Cmplx/Comm: Worthington

OfficeContract Info

MLS Entry Date: 2025-05-29

General Property Info

Total Baths: 5
Baths F.H: 4.1
Full Baths: 4
Half Baths: Yes
Built Prior to 1978: No
Garage/EnclosdSpaces: 3
Year Built: 2019
SqFt Documented: 3574
Documented SqFt Source: Realist
SqFt ATFLS: 5107
ATFLS Source: includes finished LL
Lot Size (Side): 103
Acreage: 0.21
Manufactured Housing Y/N: No
HOA/COA Y/N: No
Comm Dev Chrg: No

Tax Info

Parcel #: 100-002994
Assessment: none known
Tax Year: 2024
Tax Abatement: No
Taxes (Yrly): 16870

Remarks Misc

Directions: (Use GPS) south of New England Ave on Plymouth St to McCoy Ave.

Status Change Info

Under Contract Date: 2025-06-01
Sold Date: 2025-07-02
Sold Price/SqFt: 363.74

More Information

Bedroom Level

Beds UP1: 4
Beds Down1: Yes

Full Baths Level

Full Baths UP1: 3
Full Baths Down1: Yes

Half Baths Level

Half B Entry Level: Yes

Living Room Level

Living R Entry Level: Yes

Dining Room Level

Dining Entry Level: Yes

Eating Space Level

Eating S Entry Level: Yes

Family Room Level

Family R Entry Level: Yes

Great Room Level

Great Room Down1: Yes

Rec Room Level

Rec Room Down1: Yes

Utility Space Level

Utility Entry Level: Yes

Basement

Basement Y/N: Yes

Accessory Dwelling Unit

Existing Accessory Dwelling Unit: No

Accessible Features

Accessible Features: No

Auction Info

Auction/Online Bidding Y/N: No

Green Features

Green Features Y/N: No

Property Features

Levels: Two Architectural Style: Traditional Common Walls: No Common Walls Addl Acceptance Cond: None Known Parking Features: Attached Garage; Garage Door Opener Basement Description: Egress Window(s); Full Foundation: Poured Exterior: Brick; Cement Fiber Board; Stucco Rooms: 1st Flr Laundry; Dining Room; Eat Space/Kit; Family Rm/Non Bsmt; Great Room; Rec Rm/Bsmt Fireplace: One; Gas Log Heating: Forced Air; Gas Air Conditioning: Central Air Windows: Insulated All Interior Flooring: Carpet; Ceramic/Porcelain; Wood Sewer: Public Sewer Water Source: Public Interior Amenities: Dishwasher; Electric Dryer Hookup; Electric Range; Gas Range; Gas Water Heater Fencing: Fenced New Financing: Conventional MLS Primary PhotoSrc: Realtor Provided

Listing Office: Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

Listing Agent: Erin Ogden Oxender

Last Updated: July - 03 - 2025

The data relating to real estate for sale on this site comes from the Broker Reciprocity/IDX of Columbus Board of Realtors Multiple Listing Service.Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. Columbus Board of Realtors Multiple Listing Service does not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. Copyright 2026 Columbus Board of Realtors. All rights reserved.